Power determines the shape of the curve - concave (immediate diminishing returns) or S-shaped (threshold effects).
Critical Power Values
Power = 1.0 (Concave/ADBUG):
Best customers respond first, continuous declining ROI
Power = 1.5-1.8 (Gentle S-Shape):
Mild threshold, moderate acceleration, then saturation
Power = 1.8-2.0 (Strong S-Shape):
Clear threshold, strong acceleration, then saturation
Selecting Power
Channel Characteristic
Recommended Power
Audience sorting (best first)
1.0
Frequency fatigue
1.0
Search intent (high intent first)
1.0
Needs frequency (recall requires repetition)
1.6-2.0
Threshold effects
1.6-2.0
Viral potential
1.8-2.0
Brand building
1.6-2.0
Business Interpretation
Power = 1.0 (Pure Concave) - Use for:
Paid search (best keywords first)
Email (best customers open first)
Price promotions (price-sensitive shoppers first)
Retargeting (warmest audiences first)
Power = 1.6-2.0 (S-Shaped) - Use for:
Brand TV (need frequency for recall)
New product launches (awareness building)
Social viral campaigns (engagement threshold)
Sponsorships (credibility building)
Parameter Interaction Examples
Low Alpha + Low Power (α=0.3, power=1.0)
Early, immediate diminishing returns
Example: Small email list, quick fatigue
Low Alpha + High Power (α=0.3, power=1.8)
Early threshold with rapid acceleration
Example: Local market TV, small but responsive audience
High Alpha + Low Power (α=0.8, power=1.0)
Late but immediate diminishing returns
Example: Mature paid search with large keyword inventory
High Alpha + High Power (α=0.8, power=1.8)
Late threshold, sustained growth
Example: National brand TV, large potential reach
Practical Examples
Example 1: Digital Display Campaign
Curve: ADBUG_ATAN with α=0.4, power=1.0
What this means:
Alpha = 0.4: Saturation begins around $10K weekly
Power = 1.0: Immediate diminishing returns, best audiences first
Business insight: "Display shows immediate effectiveness but declining ROI. Best audiences exhaust around $10K/week. Cap spend around $15K/week."
Example 2: National TV Brand Campaign
Curve: ICP_ATAN with α=0.8, power=1.9
What this means:
Alpha = 0.8: Saturation at very high spend levels
Power = 1.9: Needs threshold investment, then rapid acceleration
Business insight: "TV requires ~$50K/week minimum for impact. Sweet spot $50K-$150K/week. Above $200K/week, severe diminishing returns."
How Model Coefficients Change
Without Curve:Sales = β₀ + β₁ × TV_SpendInterpretation: Constant ROI per dollar
With ATAN Curve:Sales = β₀ + β₁ × TV_Spend|ICP_ATAN_a0.5_power1.8Interpretation: β₁ on transformed value, ROI varies with spend level
This is why curve-based models enable optimization - they capture how ROI changes with spend.
Parameter Selection Process
Select variable to transform
Choose curve type (ICP or ADBUG)
Select formula (ATAN recommended)
Run tests (MixModeler tests all combinations)
Review results (sorted by R² increase)
Select winner based on:
Statistical fit (R² increase, p-value)
Business logic (does shape make sense?)
Coefficient sign (positive as expected?)
Common Mistakes
❌ Using S-shape (power > 1.5) for performance channels
❌ Using concave (power=1.0) for brand TV
❌ Alpha too low for high-reach channels
❌ Alpha too high for small audiences
✅ Best practice: Let Curve Testing guide you, validate with business intuition
Key Takeaways
Alpha controls WHERE saturation occurs
Power controls SHAPE (1.0 = concave, >1.5 = S-shape)